For eexceptionally umbral ash you offer her, she either says one generic point or the other. The Dreamchaser's Ashes are the just umbral ash in which she gains a distinct collection of dialogue when they are provided to her. This is her dialogue: After providing her Dreamchaser's Ashes

"Ashen One, what woeful umbral ash is this. This barren dust, stuff of a fool, on't yield aught. Wright here did thou happen upon the stuff? Tell me, for the sport. "

Telling her where you found the ash

"Oh, yes, I watch... Clinging to lofty dreams in this dying people...more's the pity. It need to come from one a lot of foolish indeed. Woulds't thou not agree? "

Why does she have so a lot negative points to say after providing her these ashes?


If you look at the symbol for the Dreamchaser's Ashes, you deserve to view it is a hand also gripping a pendant. This is most likely a reference to Dark Souls 1, where tbelow was a pendant item that did absolutely nothing. The game tells you that it did nopoint, yet Hidetaka Miyazaki (the game's creator) implied in an intercheck out that it had actually a mystery attribute.

You are watching: Tell her where you found the ash

Many players spent hours and also hrs trying stvariety and also unintuitive series of actions to figure out what the pendant did. The Shrine Handmaiden is making fun of those players who didn't believe the game when it told them that the pendant truly had actually no use.

my speculation is the ash belonged to someone in the family, holy knight hodrick is sirris' grandpa, and the handmaiden is her grandmommy. before you offer her the ash sirris doesn't desire much to execute with you, though she does keep things civil, however after you provide the ash she vows to assist you on your journey. it clearly states the undead was on a journey to sign up with the undead legion, echoing hawkwood's passing comment about undead still clinging to lofty dreams or somepoint prefer that, however was never heard from aobtain, the handmaiden simply desires to know just how close their grandson obtained to achieving their dream.

i likewise assume its not the ash itself that's responsible for the new wares at the maiden, however possibly a unique stock she was saving for someone she wanted to reprimary safe.

See more: Winning A Falsely Accused Domestic Violence Case, Domestic Violence And False Accusations

edit: i view you put the handmaiden's dialogue in the main post which proves it wasn't hawkwood's comment, however the maiden herself. her tone provides me think she kbrand-new the perboy the ash belonged to quite well.