Share all sharing choices for: Batman v Superman: Dawn the Justice: 19 points that don"t make sense in this nonsensical movie


*
Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman spend another day in ~ the office. Warner Bros.

Needless come say, major spoilers for the whole of Batman v Superman follow

I have the right to overlook plot holes; every story has actually them. Heck, also the stories you tell around your very own life have plot holes, since nobody has time come recount every solitary incident that happened, every assumed you had.

You are watching: Batman v superman is she with you

That"s all plot holes are, usually: details we just don"t have that we shouldn"t problem too much about missing as lengthy as everything rather is working.


The problem arises when the plot holes room so large that they end up being sucking voids, devouring everything around them. And things only gain worse as soon as characters" actions and also emotional logic room jerked roughly by the dictates that the plot.

Batman v Superman has actually a many plot holes. Some are nitpicks. Some room minor and also can more than likely be waved away. Some are legitimate story problems. But what"s unforgivable is how plenty of moments that character-defying illogic the movie contains. Castle erode to trust in its ability to phone call this details story.

Here are 19 moments from Batman v Superman that simply don"t make sense, ranked by exactly how much they damage the film.

1) Why is Batman so cursed gullible?

*
Cool Bat Signal, though. Warner Bros. The entire movie hinges top top Lex Luthor utilizing his wiles to trick Batman and also Superman right into fighting. However he doesn"t really waste much energy on fooling Superman, who"s barely aware that Batman has actually it in for him.

Instead, the spends almost the entire movie picking at the scab that is Bruce Wayne"s anger end the Metropolis disaster that concluded Man the Steel. (That movie famously ended with a battle between Superman and also General Zod that damaged much that the city"s downtown area, with much loss of chaste life.)

Batman v Superman"s solitary best idea is the Batman has decided Superman is a problem because of the chaos the resulted at the end of that earlier film. Arising the film directly from that dispute could have given Batman v Superman the thoughtful weight it so plainly aspires to, and also maybe even a touch of political commentary here and there.

Instead, Batman is for this reason single-minded the he comes off prefer a finish idiot. He can"t figure out that a well known crime lord is actually a boat. That misses the noticeable ways Luthor is manipulating him (or simply doesn"t care). And he doesn"t seem an especially interested in Diana Prince (Wonder Woman) beyond her attractiveness, even though the might benefit him to have her as a partner.

The Batman the the comics is a rich guy with several wonderful toys, yes. Yet he"s also a supergenius. Batman v Superman"s Batman is little an ext than a repertoire of muscles.

2) exactly how does the world feel about Superman?

The film posits a world in i beg your pardon Superman"s existence has thrown person life into chaos. Some civilization worship him. Some civilization think he"s a essential evil. Still rather think he"s a substantial danger to our species.

There"s a good version that this story whereby the conflict plays out in full, wherein the moment when the human being has no choice but to death Superman — with a nuclear missile! — tote a devastating weight due to the fact that the superhero has finally re-earned ours trust.

Batman v Superman is no that film. Metropolis boasts a huge monument to the male — built just 18 month after the occasions of Man that Steel! — however it seems prefer basically nobody likes him. The world"s opinion that Superman transforms from step to scene, and seems together barely urged as a mob of Springfielders ~ above The Simpsons.

And it"s not tough to view why. In the few smaller moments wherein Superman rescues world in scene shot favor Creed album covers, he largely mopes his way through every little thing he does. I"d be sort of tired of him too.

3) Why does everybody reference Superman because that the massacre in Africa?

The deaths in "Nairomi, Africa" (seriously an unforgivable dateline) room blamed ~ above Superman, because he proved up. Yet why? everybody in that courtyard was demonstrably killed with one of two people a bullet or a bomb — and the government also knows this, past the CIA shenanigans happening about the edges.

You deserve to probably tide this one far if you really try, yet Batman v Superman simply assumes the Superman would be blamed because that such one event. I"m not so sure that would certainly be the case.

4) What the hell is Wonder woman in Metropolis for?

She tells us this, actually: She"s there to retrieve the picture Luthor has of her from when she to be fighting in people War I. However later, she states she "left the human being of men," presumably to return to wherever she comes from in the DC Cinematic Universe.

So why go she require the photo? If she"s no hanging out about normal humans, no one that looks at it will understand who she is. They could think it weird to check out an Amazon in the trenches of world War I, but so lengthy as she stays secluded, she"s fine. Instead, she comes out of isolation to track down the photo?

Her illustration would have actually made more sense if she simply randomly proved up come fight the knevish monster Doomsday — and also that would have actually been terrible!

5) What go Lex Luthor want?

*
Obviously just to hang the end at his cool office. Warner Bros. To destroy Superman, sure. Yet why? Batman v Superman can"t comprise its mind.

First he"s simply a society climber. Then he hates God since his father was abusive? Maybe? Later, he desires to be God by developing Doomsday. But we don"t learn about Doomsday"s visibility until awfully so late in the plot, and the only reason is watch to have Superman perish at the hands of the brute.

Nowhere walk Batman v Superman expose its true roots as Warner Bros. Attempts to awkwardly mash increase two standard comics — The Dark items Returns and The fatality of Superman — to handmade Luthor"s motivations, which change depending ~ above the scene.

6) Is Lois roadway magic?

When she"s no being hosted captive as a damsel in distress, Lois Lane offers her strength of journalism to instantly arrive ~ above the scene of where she"s needed, come the degree that she deserve to throw herself right into the middle of Batman and also Superman"s large fight. (Though at least that enntrance gate is explained: She takes a helicopter.)

Lois lane is a great, great character the both of Zack Snyder"s Superman movies have bad misunderstood. Numerous have made fun of her line in Batman v Superman, "I"m not a lady. I"m a journalist." however it provides sense if you think that Snyder and his screenwriters think journalists are prefer the elves from The Lord of the Rings — always showing up in ~ the last feasible moment but also always reflecting up.

7) Corollary: Why do Clark Kent and also Lois roadway love each other?

*
difficult to say! Warner Bros. prize this question for me using only the material found in Man of stole and Batman v Superman. Don"t talk around their love story native the comics or from other Superman films. I"ll wait.

8) Why go Batman decide no to death Superman?

The film"s most mocked minute is already the part where Batman decides no to kill Superman because both of their moms are called Martha. But even if you placed aside the sheer ridiculousness of the situation, it leans much too heavily on one abrupt emotional shift.

You have the right to sort of view what everybody was going for: just as he"s about to walk murder, Batman remembers the killing that identified his childhood.

But Batman has spent so long fretting about Superman — with at the very least a somewhat justifiable kernel at the core of his rage — that his sudden change of heart seems bizarre. Why would certainly he immediately become Superman"s ally? even if Batman decided not to kill him, part mistrust would still remain, surely.

9) Similarly, why doesn"t Superman lead v the most pertinent information when confronting Batman?

Opening with, "Lex Luthor is manipulating us into fighting, and he"s walking to murder my mommy if we don"t job-related together. I deserve to prove it," seems like a more powerful strategy than simply vaguely declaring, "We must work together," but what do I know?

10) Even an ext similarly, what is Batman"s plan for gaining Superman come fight him?

He turns on the Bat Signal, then waits roughly an exit warehouse? Sure, that works, yet it seems favor he stands roughly for a long, lengthy time before Superman mirrors up. Batman"s a proactive character. Wouldn"t he take it the fight come his foe?

11) If Batman to know so much around Lex Luthor"s shady smuggling deals, why doesn"t he suspect Luthor"s true intentions?

He knows Luthor is maintaining an eye top top so-called "metahumans" too, for this reason you"d think he would at the very least be a small suspicious. I realize this is simply an expansion of my very an initial point, yet that really, really bugged me.

12) Why is everything in this movie at the very least two story beats too complicated?

*
Lois doesn"t should be kidnapped for this story come work. Warner Bros. Lois gift a damsel in distress make me roll my eyes, yet at the very least Superman dropping whatever to rescue her kind of makes sense within the movie"s own twisted logic. They love each other — or therefore they say.

But then it transforms out Luthor is simply using Lois being in danger to attract Superman out right into the open, prior to revealing he"s carry away Superman"s mommy as well.

Setting next Batman v Superman"s lousy therapy of its women characters, both females don"t need to be captured for this story to do sense. Similarly, the movie doesn"t require both the afri massacre and the to explode in the united state Capitol for Superman to feel bad about the chaos he"s carried to the world. Many of Batman v Superman"s story is pointless busywork.

13) Why doesn"t Superman listen the bomb in the wheelchair?

The Capitol battle sequence is a chaos on a number of levels — considering it requires Luthor threatening a sitting us senator with a jar full of urine, because that one — yet it all drops apart when you realize the Superman could nearly certainly hear the bomb within of Wallace"s wheelchair. (Thanks to derekwadsworth.com contributor Genevieve Valentine because that pointing this out.)

14) exactly how is the everyday Planet a functioning business?

*
Perry White talks just in headlines. Warner Bros. no one likes it when journalists complain about fictional depictions the journalism, yet this is a specifically egregious one. Perry White has no attention in a story around Batman? He"s gained Clark extending football, but additionally attending society parties? perhaps the earth doesn"t have actually beats anymore, however no real-world journalist operates prefer that. (I can go on, but I feeling this certain topic will certainly be that interest mostly to me.)

15) exactly how does the Kryptonian ship simply decide Luthor will be its brand-new master?

The answer to this question is, "Because the story requirements that come happen." That"s rarely a great sign.

16) Why go Superman die?

*
Bruce and also Diana have a change of love after Superman dies. Warner Bros. Okay, top top a technical level, I understand why he die — Doomsday bone-fragments him v the heart.

But why does his fatality have to happen on a object level? What about it inspires Bruce and also Diana to start the justice League? and why bother v it in ~ all, offered that it will plainly immediately be reversed in the Justice League movie (still ostensibly coming in 2017)?

Death has end up being a brief means station on the hero"s trip in also many contemporary Hollywood franchises. Just once, death and also resurrection should bring some cursed weight. Castle don"t have any kind of weight in Batman v Superman. In ~ all.

17) What"s the allude of Clark"s dream visit through his dad?

No matter what you do, or how tough you work to conserve people, something might go wrong ... And also then a bunch of steeds will drown, Jonathan Kent serious intones. So also though it"s great to help people, possibly you shouldn"t.

If anyone to be surprised that Snyder wants to adapt The Fountainhead for an upcoming project, hope they won"t it is in after this baffling bit of characterization.

18) does anybody in this cosmos know exactly how to usage a spear?

Spears are made to be thrown! just throw the spear at Doomsday! Mission accomplished!

(Also, maybe don"t litter a fatal spear into a gigantic pool that water, climate decide you want it back a couple of minutes later. Maybe wait till after the giant battle with a deformed alien monster to decision what to do with it.)

19) WTF to be Batman"s dream sequence?

*
Zack Snyder hangs the end on set, getting us ready for all the movie to come. Warner Bros. Batman falls asleep — or probably travels come the future?! — while waiting for files to decrypt. When he does, that imagines a human being in i beg your pardon Superman has taken over, seemingly together Darkseid, the main big, cosmic bad of the DC Comics universe. Climate the Flash access time him to deliver a message about being right and needing to find Lois Lane.

And that"s it. I realize the simple explanation because that the dream sequence is, "It"s setting up future movies," or, "It shows us Batman"s paranoia about Superman!" (Batman, apparently, is a recently activated authoritarian.) however it likewise seems like an attempt to gain us to concern that Superman can turn evil at some point, and, sigh.

No matter just how you part it, Batman v Superman doesn"t work as a standalone movie. But in this succession — which could be lifted the end of the movie without transforming anything — that doesn"t occupational as a potential franchise starter, either. And also for Warner Bros., that can be the element of Batman v Superman that makes the the very least sense of all.

See more: How To Use Peppermint Oil For Toothache S, How To Use Essential Oils For Toothache

Batman v Superman is playing throughout the country. Check out something else instead.